America’s Got Talent Season 9 Top 12 Live Recap and Videos

3. Sons of Serendip (Group/Singers) . The group perform “Ordinary World” by Duran Duran. The lead singer turns in a grand and gorgeous performance. Howard felt they did it perfectly tonight. “A wonderful emotional moment.” Heidi calls it grand and majestic. Mel says they nail it time and time again. They really stepped up to the plate, she says.

4. Christian Stoinev and Scooby. The performance opens with a music video in which Scooby is on the run from law enforcement. Howie and Mel B are high on Christian, with Mel B in particular calling this one of his best performances. Heidi, meanwhile, feels as though there’s still a lack of balance between the dog and the hand balancing. Howie felt Christian stepped it up. Howard congratulates him for taking in his constructive criticism. “You can go to bed tonight, proud of yourself,” he says.