Paige Thomas performed “What Is Love” by Haddaway on The X Factor USA 2012 Top 16 first performance night on Wednesday, October 31.

The judges: LA it “feels like stardom, but I’m not so sure about that song choice.” Britney says, “You’re outrageous. I think you are a true star.” Simon says, “You’ve just come out here tonight and nailed it. It was so annoying watching this one’s smug little face.” Simon likes the song choice. Demi says, “I’m so unbelievable proud of you. I’m shaking. What a great way to open up the show.”

Watch the video below.