Jeffrey Gutt, 36, performed “Hallelujah” by Leonard Cohen on The X Factor USA Season 2 audition Thursday night, September 20.

“I think you are unbelievable. You nailed it. I am a fan,” says LA. “I love how mysterious your voice was. Soothing,” says Britney. “Amazing grit. I never heard it sung like that. God is rocking out right now.” Simon says, “It was one of the most brilliant auditions I’ve heard.” Demi calls him “The Josh Groban of Rock n Roll.” Simon says, “Better.”

Jeffrey got four yeses from the judges.

Tell us what you think of his performance. Watch the video below.