Jason Brock, 34, performed his own version of “New York State of Mind” Thursday night, September 13, 2012. After his performance, L.A. Reid gave him a standing ovation followed by Britney and Demi.

Even Simon was impressed for whatever reason. “When you were talking about this ridiculous concert that I never thought was going to happen and it was all fantasy, and I was preparing myself for the worst — but we saw your concert. I loved your audition.”

“It was magnificento!” Spears exclaimed. “I was very entertained, thank you!”